Robert Irwin "Nine Spaces, Nine Trees" at University of Washington

For years, the Robert Irwin installation Nine Spaces, Nine Trees seemed almost indistinguishable from the grim, functional office building it accompanied.  Driving past, Nine Spaces didn’t even look, at first glance, like art but more of a construction site, with tall fences walling off a sad group of potted trees.  Why wander through what looked like a feed lot for plants, with nothing but the local jail for company?

By all accounts Irwin, a by-now legendary pioneer of public installation art with a career spanning nearly half a century, gave a great deal of thought to the specifics of his south downtown location.  The nine trees and nine spaces were a response to the demands of the site, actually the top of a parking garage where the spacing of nine support columns determined both what could be built (it couldn’t weigh much) and the spacing of Irwin’s plum trees.  The chain-link fence was meant to both fit in with and transcend the workaday setting. 

Irwin’s installation art has always been about perception and awareness, and people writing about his work often mention the need to experience the pieces over time, as the effects that Irwin is aiming at aren’t always obvious at first sight.  This is certainly true about Nine Spaces, where only by walking in and around the various “rooms” defined by the high fenced walls can one appreciate the visual interactions that Irwin intended.   But for many years after its completion, few people bothered.

The new location is much, much more welcoming.  No comparison!  But it’s still an open question how many casual viewers will detour into Irwin’s outdoor grid, no matter how artfully conceived.  There is something distinctly off-putting about the banal materials: concrete pavers, aluminum poles, and 20’ tall, chain link fencing.  Even as I grew to appreciate the piece, I couldn’t shake the association with similarly walled-off urban spaces: car lots, paved-over playgrounds, and storage yards.  The large, potted trees don’t necessarily help much, as many of our most lifeless urban spaces are decorated with similar forest remnants, as though our aversion can be conquered simply by reminding us of what we’ve lost.  We don’t warm up to these sterile plazas, food courts, and shopping centers, simply because they have plantings, but that’s not really what Irwin’s Nine Spaces is about.

Irwin thinks much more like a painter than an urban planner, though he hasn’t touched brush to canvas for at least 30 years.  In the spirit of Mondrian, he uses the chain-link fencing material as paint, employing its bright purple color to create a gridded, geometrical abstraction distantly related to the work of his Dutch predecessor, but it is an abstraction that shifts and changes as one changes position.   And it’s this element that’s key to the entire piece, the visual dance between transparency and opacity, public/private, color/no color, inside/outside. 

Irwin plays on the fact that viewed at various angles, chain-link can act like a theatrical scrim, which can both hide and reveal what’s behind it.  At certain junctures whole section of the fencing transform into a row of intensely-colored, lavender rectangles, vivid as painted panels the sunny day I visited, and vividly framed by the gleaming aluminum poles – like a section of a Mondrian, but made up of metal, light and air. 

Walk a few feet further, and the illusion of solidity breaks up, and we once again look through the fence, not at it.  The “painting” has dematerialized.  Neat! 

Irwin plays similar games with layering.  Since the purple fencing walls off 9 partly-enclosed, individual spaces, each with its one Hawthorn tree and seating unit, there are often several layers of fence between you and the farthest-away cubicle, creating varying levels of privacy depending on where one sits.  The central three spaces are the most open to the outside, part of the natural passageway through the grid, but those seeking more sanctuary can choose to be in on of the less-exposed side units.   The enclosure thus becomes a sort of miniature city, where we can maintain the illusion of being alone while at the same time seeing and being seen, depending on where and how we choose to pay attention.  It also creates a sense of being in a “room”, while in fact there is nothing of the sort, as there are no doors to close, no roof to separate us from the sky, and no protection at all from the elements.

The trees are an oddly ironic presence, especially in the semi-forested campus setting, so unlike the original downtown locale.  Walking past, surrounded by groves of “wild” trees, it seems  curious that these particular trees are walled off; are they being protected from us, or we from them?  On the other hand, the nine trees have visual part to play in their interactions with the sculpture, both in their changing transparency as they lose or gain foliage, and the way their orange fruit, when ripe, will play off the purple field surrounding them.  They also serve to anchor each individual space, on a pedestal like an art object in the center of every room.

If there’s an overriding weakness to the piece, it comes from the fact that it was conceived for one site, and installed in another.  I’m not convinced that the fence idea was a particularly successful response to the original surroundings of Nine Spaces, and I’m even less convinced that it makes a lot of sense on a leafy college campus, where it loses any resonance with its environment that it might have once had.  I appreciate Nine Spaces and the visual rewards it offers, but it’s hard to imagine it not seeming like a permanent intruder, an industrial insertion in a pastoral setting.  It’s a reminder that while contemporary art offers much to delight the eye and engage the mind, it has never found a secure or consistent place in our public realm, rarely finding the kind of dialogue with its built surroundings that one experiences in older European cities, where urban art and architecture often coexist so beautifully. 

Share |

Comments

May 8. 2008 02:20

Jim Demetre

Gary,

This is great assessment of Irwin's 're-sited' work. I wrote this post on the Artdish Forum in December after I saw it for the first time:

www.artdish.com/.../ultimatebb.cgi

Jim Demetre

May 8. 2008 08:26

will renege

I think this is a good review.  

Something else that bothers me about the piece is how it just ends at the orange brick wall, that low wall that forms the edge of the outdoor seating area between Odegard and Nine Spaces.

I don't know if Nine Spaces is even art or if the original installation was art, or if the thousands of other installations like it are.    What makes this different from the slabs of stone Buster Simpson laid out in Belltown years ago?  The Simpson slabs aren't art.  (When I moved to town, I didn't know what they were.  I went around asking the Belltown merchants if I could buy the stone in front of their stores.)  Maybe, like Gary writes, if these pieces had a secure place in our public realm and coexisted, I'd feel different.

will renege

May 8. 2008 09:33

Jim Demetre

A person feels rather trapped when entering the piece, don't you think? In fact, it reminds me of something I've seen before on TV:

img.timeinc.net/time/daily/2006/0603/log0302.jpg

Jim Demetre

May 9. 2008 04:37

pingback

Pingback from hankblog.wordpress.com

Nine Spaces, Nine Trees « Hankblog

hankblog.wordpress.com

January 13. 2009 16:10

saville row tailors

Cool post - I just wish their had been something this clever at the UNI I went to in the UK.

saville row tailors

January 13. 2009 16:11

mediation service

Thanks for the post,I was looking for things to do when I come across for a conference so I am going to make sure i check this out when I am on Campus

mediation service

January 13. 2009 16:13

croydon solicitors

Does it really not fit in the new space it has? I wonder what would have been built if it was known it was going to be for a completely different location

croydon solicitors

January 14. 2009 05:23

Busby Test

Hi, that nice post, Robert Irwin "Nine Spaces, Nine Trees" at University of Washington.
Thanks.

Busby Test

January 22. 2009 23:44

Cottages in Devon

Quality post... it amazes me that they even did it.

Cottages in Devon

January 28. 2009 11:54

treatment rooms London

This is a cool review and inspiring. Looking out the window of my drab uni library I can only wish of something as beautiful and arty as this.

treatment rooms London

March 18. 2009 12:54

cake decorating

What ever might be the inspiration of such a design. I don't really like it. - Ann

cake decorating

March 20. 2009 15:06

food quotes collection


Finally, got what I was looking for!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it. Glad I stumbled into this article! smile I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post

food quotes collection

April 13. 2009 15:24

make perfume

I like more subtle designs which blend in well rather than in your face stuff. Nicole

make perfume

April 16. 2009 12:25

md5 hash

what a nice post. this is what i'm looking for. thanks.

md5 hash

June 9. 2009 12:49

buying property

I like it so much.

buying property

July 6. 2009 11:36

club penguin cheats

I don't know if Nine Spaces is even art or if the original installation was art, or if the thousands of other installations like it are. What makes this different from the slabs of stone Buster Simpson laid out in Belltown years ago?

club penguin cheats

July 15. 2009 18:37

ladies perfume

Very nice indeed

ladies perfume

July 21. 2009 01:59

ladies perfume

quality post

ladies perfume

August 5. 2009 11:23

free online games

I liked it very much.

free online games

August 7. 2009 10:30

work at home

the best university and a nice post.

work at home

August 7. 2009 10:32

diet plans

awesome post and i have bookmarked this page.

diet plans

August 10. 2009 15:54

casino de apuestas

Thanks a ton for the code. And the tutorial is nice too. But thanks once again for sharing this code.

casino de apuestas

August 13. 2009 03:36

acai burn reviews

Very interesting topic.  I will bookmark your site to check if you write more about in the future. I am quite interested in this topic. I just hope you will elaborate more on it in future posts.

acai burn reviews

August 13. 2009 10:50

Massagers

I am proud to have studied in the University!

Robert

Massagers

August 18. 2009 17:44

Employment

Thanks for the good plantations tips. I have seen a lot of plantation by these methods.
Regards,

Employment

August 26. 2009 19:50

best teeth whitening

great post and thanks for sharing.

best teeth whitening

September 2. 2009 17:53

anti-aging

This site is raelly awsome.Thanku for shareing the posts
Regards,

anti-aging

September 4. 2009 11:04

Airport parking Sydney

This site states many topics useful to everyone. I have bookmarked this site. Thanks,

Airport parking Sydney

September 5. 2009 13:38

Naughty Monkey Boots

simply amazing

Naughty Monkey Boots

September 7. 2009 04:35

Tattoo Designs

Irwin is a great urban planner and he seems to have a unique ability to blend his work in with the surrounding environment.

Tattoo Designs

September 10. 2009 20:02

London Tours

I wish they had that my my college - nice.

London Tours

September 14. 2009 11:29

lab coats

i like the post very much.

lab coats

September 14. 2009 21:16

payday online

I havent any word to appreciate this post.....Really i am impressed from this post....the person who create this post it was a great human..thanks for shared this with us.

payday online

September 15. 2009 04:20

payday online

Pretty good post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts.Any way Ill be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon

payday online

September 15. 2009 07:48

payday online

I havent any word to appreciate this post.....Really i am impressed from this post....the person who create this post it was a great human..thanks for shared this with us.

payday online

September 15. 2009 10:34

payday online

I havent any word to appreciate this post.....Really i am impressed from this post....the person who create this post it was a great human..thanks for shared this with us.

payday online

September 15. 2009 10:45

payday online

I havent any word to appreciate this post.....Really i am impressed from this post....the person who create this post it was a great human..thanks for shared this with us.

payday online

September 16. 2009 13:12

payday loans

Easy option to get useful information as well as share good stuff with good ideas and concepts

payday loans

September 16. 2009 14:11

free extra chips

If the thousands of other installations like it are. What makes this different from the slabs of stone Buster Simpson laid out in Belltown years ago?
Regards,

free extra chips

September 16. 2009 22:04

Free online games

Very interesting post..I was looking for things to do when I come across for a conference so I am going to make sure i check this out when I am on Campus.

Free online games

September 21. 2009 11:54

payday loans

We are a group of volunteers and starting a new initiative in a community. Your blog provided us valuable information to work on.You have done a marvellous job!

payday loans

September 21. 2009 20:54

payday loans

We are a group of volunteers and starting a new initiative in a community. Your blog provided us valuable information to work on.You have done a marvellous job!

payday loans

September 21. 2009 23:45

payday loans

We are a group of volunteers and starting a new initiative in a community. Your blog provided us valuable information to work on.You have done a marvellous job!

payday loans

September 21. 2009 23:58

payday loans

We are a group of volunteers and starting a new initiative in a community. Your blog provided us valuable information to work on.You have done a marvellous job!

payday loans

September 23. 2009 23:30

how to quit smoking

Pretty good post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts.Any way Ill be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon

how to quit smoking

September 25. 2009 09:19

Ameda Ultra

I liked reading this one, reminds me of my early days of life, really very nice, thank you fore the share.


Dave

Ameda Ultra

September 25. 2009 16:29

how to get pregnant

This is nice site to watch.will bookmark your site to check if you write more about in the future. I am quite interested in this topic. I just hope you will elaborate more on it in future posts.Thanks for shareing the posts.
Regards

how to get pregnant

September 26. 2009 13:39

colon cleanser

This site contains really wonderful posts to watch.I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts.Any way Ill be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon.Thanks for shareing the posts.
Regards,

colon cleanser

September 30. 2009 17:10

forex trading software

I will bookmark your site to check if you write more about in the future. I am quite interested in this topic. I just hope you will elaborate more on it in future posts.Thanks for shareing.
Regards,

forex trading software

October 2. 2009 22:01

Trade Show Podiums

This site contains really wonderful posts to watch.I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts.Any way Ill be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon.Thanks for shareing the posts.
Regards,

Trade Show Podiums

October 3. 2009 15:18

wedding dresses

By all accounts Irwin, a by-now legendary pioneer of public installation art with a career spanning nearly half a century, gave a great deal of thought to the specifics of his south downtown location

wedding dresses

October 8. 2009 14:37

migliori giocate al casinò di Internet

Very interesting post..I was looking for things to do when I come across for a conference so I am going to make sure i check this out when I am on Campus.

migliori giocate al casinò di Internet

October 12. 2009 13:55

Search Universities

I found lots of interesting information here. The post was professionally written and I feel like the author has extensive knowledge in the subject.

Search Universities

October 12. 2009 13:55

Online University Study

You made some good points there. I did a search on the topic and found most people will agree with your blog.

Online University Study

October 12. 2009 13:56

University Degrees Online

Hi, I can't understand how to add your site in my rss reader. Can you Help me, please

University Degrees Online

October 12. 2009 13:56

Special Education

Your post left me quenching for more Your post really gives out useful knowledge.

Special Education

October 14. 2009 15:36

SIA Licence

I am thankful for such a great post with many new things to learn. Thanks, you cleared up some things for me.

SIA Licence

October 14. 2009 23:19

personal loans

Interesting post

personal loans

October 15. 2009 00:28

personal loans

Interesting ... as always - is your blog making any cash advance ? ;)

personal loans

October 15. 2009 11:05

medifast coupon

i agree that urban art and architecture often coexist so beautifully.  

medifast coupon

October 15. 2009 19:58

cash advance

Do you make money out of this blog? just curious

cash advance

October 20. 2009 12:40

Apex Professionals LLC

I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed reading your blog posts.Any way Ill be subscribing to your feed and I hope you post again soon.Thanks for shareing the posts.
Regards,

Apex Professionals LLC

January 12. 2010 13:52

forex

Here aremy currencies predictionsfor this year:Euro/Dollar:1.2050Pound/Dollar:1.2980USD/JPY:90.70Usd/Chf:1.1560I wonder if I will be rightwhen the year ends..Smile

forex

January 12. 2010 23:32

Refinancing Mortgage Loan Debt Consolidation

Thanks a lot for that exceedingly cool column!

Refinancing Mortgage Loan Debt Consolidation

January 12. 2010 23:40

hoiw to get your ex back

nice working place.

check this out on how to get your ex back.
www.zimbio.com/.../How+to+Get+Your+Ex+Back

hoiw to get your ex back

January 13. 2010 01:50

Larry Kantarian

Hi, I found this blog post while was searching for perfumessupply related information on blog search and found it very good article, thanks for sharing, best regards and cheers!

Larry Kantarian

January 13. 2010 17:51

Teeth Whitener Risks

That is an extremely awe inspiring post you've posted here!

Teeth Whitener Risks

January 13. 2010 19:17

Vivien Rizzuti

Great blog!i really enjoyed reading your posts.i've also bookmarked your feed to stay in touch with your news.

Vivien Rizzuti

January 13. 2010 19:32

Gwyneth Havercroft

Hey, <B>Your Blog</B> is very good, found while in search for wedding info on cuil.com and it has very related information on it. Will be sure to come back again and bookmark, thanks

Gwyneth Havercroft

January 13. 2010 22:27

Chest Hair Transplants

That is an extremely awesome column you've posted!

Chest Hair Transplants

January 14. 2010 10:48

tetris online

Hey site owner, thank you very much for providing this information... I found it gorgeous. Cheers, Isabell!!!!

tetris online

January 14. 2010 22:14

tetris game

Incredible blog post.I've bookmarked it already. Best regards, Oswald.

tetris game

January 15. 2010 03:18

Free Articles

Nice site to visit! I admire your writing and the way you explain things. Some of the comments on here too are insightful. I appreciate you. keep it up!

Free Articles

February 2. 2010 17:41

hp coupons

well done..

hp coupons

February 4. 2010 11:50

medifast coupons

Thanks for the help.

medifast coupons

February 23. 2010 18:38

farmville secrets

If you really want to learn how to grow your farm fast, then check out this Farmville secrets guide today.

farmville secrets

February 28. 2010 13:27

Fatcow

Should I get a VPS? Right now I am using lunarpages but they keep disabling my account due to high server overload. Im getting about 4,000 unique views a day. What brand should I get?

Fatcow

March 3. 2010 01:23

wow mobiles

WoW Mobile is awesome! I get free mobile service with t-mobile because I refered 3 people to wow. You can too!

wow mobiles

March 12. 2010 01:12

comforter sets

Hello folks, I would suggest that you try to change comment system. mike

comforter sets

Add comment


(Will show your Gravatar icon)

  Country flag

biuquote
  • Comment
  • Preview
Loading



artdishnorthwest forum on visual art